Breads and Buns
We make your bread fresh on Wednesdays and Fridays, so any order with bread will be processed on those days and can be picked up in the afternoon. Please note: Bread orders may be cancelled or pushed to a different day without notice if not enough orders have been received.
Our pies and pie pastry are made from scratch using fresh fruit (in season), fresh frozen fruits and other fresh ingredients. They are 9" in size. The pastry is made using lard, but vegetable shortening can be requested. Fancier pastry tops and crumble tops can also be substituted, just use the modification button to create your perfect pie! Gluten free options are not available. Please note: Sometimes pies will "boil out", breaking open the pastry a bit, darkening edges, covering letters, designs, braids, etc. This occurs during the baking process and cannot be helped. No discounts or refunds will be given for the less "pretty" pies. Fruit Pies are either $16 or $18 each.
Soft, chewy and delicious...unless they are supposed to be crisp! Please note: We typically package our cookies in dozens, but on occasion the cookies get too big and we can only fit ten or eleven in the package. We will try to remember to tell you on pick up if this happens, but just be aware that you may only see ten or eleven in there!
The Sweet Shoppe offers a wide selection of delicious squares, although not all may be readily available since there are so many varieties. Feel free to send a message if you are looking for something special or have a craving for something not listed! Squares can be made into platters for events such as weddings, reunions, meetings, funerals or corporate gifts. Platters have 5 or 10 dozen bite sized pieces, each in a paper cup for sanitary, easy serving.
Our Cream Pies are made fresh for you on the day of pick up. Please note that we require a minimum of 3 business days to fit cream pie orders into our baking schedule. Coconut Cream Pie, Chocolate Cream Pie and Banana Cream Pie have a pastry base with a whipped cream top, Flapper Pie has a graham crust base with a meringue top. Lemon Meringue Pie has a pastry base with a meringue top. Key Lime Pie has a chocolate cookie base with a whipped cream top. Please use the modification buttons if you prefer combinations other than those listed above. Decorative piping may vary from what is pictured.